Sale Leaseback Real Estate Transactions: Strategic Insights for Owners and Investors

by Matthew Hoover

In today’s dynamic real estate environment, sale/leaseback transactions are gaining momentum as a strategic financial tool for both property owners and investors. Especially relevant in industrial, office, and retail sectors, this structure allows businesses to unlock capital while retaining operational control of the property. Whether you’re a business owner evaluating capital strategies or an investor seeking stable, long-term income, understanding the nuances of a sale/leaseback is critical. In this article, we will look at the advantages and disadvantages of a sale/leaseback transaction as well as the methodology for evaluating whether a sale/leaseback is a beneficial financial tool for your business.

What is a Sale/Leaseback?

A sale/leaseback (SLB) is a financial transaction in which a property owner sells a real estate asset and simultaneously leases it back from the buyer. The lease agreement—typically long-term—allows the original owner to continue occupying and using the property as a tenant. This structure separates the operating business from the underlying real estate, converting an illiquid asset into liquid capital while retaining operational continuity.

Purpose of a Sale/Leaseback

The primary purpose of a sale/leaseback is to free up capital tied in real estate without disrupting business operations. It is particularly attractive for companies that own mission-critical properties—such as headquarters, warehouses, or manufacturing plants—but want to redeploy capital into core business activities, reduce debt, or fund growth initiatives.

For investors, SLBs present a unique opportunity to acquire a stabilized, income-producing asset backed by a corporate tenant with an established operating history.

Benefits for the Seller/Tenant

1. Improved Liquidity

A sale/leaseback allows businesses to unlock capital that would otherwise remain tied up in real estate. These proceeds can be reinvested into higher-return initiatives or used to strengthen the balance sheet.

2. Operational Control

Most SLB agreements involve long-term, triple-net (NNN) leases, allowing the tenant to maintain uninterrupted use and control of the property, often with renewal options.

3. Tax Advantages

Lease payments become fully deductible as an operating expense, potentially improving tax efficiency compared to depreciation on owned assets.

4. Off-Balance Sheet Financing

In some cases, the lease obligations can be structured to keep liabilities off the balance sheet (subject to lease accounting standards), improving financial ratios.

Drawbacks for the Seller/Tenant

1. Loss of Property Appreciation

Once the asset is sold, any future appreciation accrues to the buyer, not the original owner.

2. Long-Term Lease Commitment

The tenant is typically locked into a long-term lease. This can reduce flexibility, especially if business needs or locations change.

3. Perception and Control

Some businesses may view the loss of real estate ownership as reducing strategic control or stability, especially in uncertain markets.

Evaluating Financial Viability

Before executing a sale/leaseback, it’s essential to assess the financial implications:

1. Cap Rate vs. Cost of Capital

Sellers should compare the cap rate (i.e., sale price divided by annual rent) to their discount rate. For a public company this is typically the weighted average cost of capital (WACC). For a private company, this may be the cost of funds or the opportunity cost of funds deployed in another investment or reinvested in the grown of the company. If the capital from a sale/leaseback can be redeployed at a higher return than the cap rate, the transaction is accretive.

2. Net Present Value (NPV) of Lease Payments

A discounted cash flow analysis should be performed to determine the present value of future lease obligations and compare it to the value of owning.

3. Impact on Financial Ratios

Consider how the transaction affects key ratios, such as return on assets (ROA), debt-to-equity, and EBITDA margins.

4. Alternative Financing

Compare SLB to other financing options like secured debt or lines of credit. While SLBs avoid debt, they come with long-term lease liabilities that should be weighed carefully.

IRR in the Context of Sale/Leaseback vs. Ownership

Beyond the analysis above, the Internal Rate of Return (IRR) is a powerful tool for evaluating whether a tenant (i.e., the owner-occupier of a property) should pursue a sale/leaseback or continue to own and operate the real estate.

IRR measures the annualized rate of return on an investment based on projected future cash flows and the initial investment (or capital outlay). In this scenario, a business evaluates two competing options:

  • Retain ownership of the property and operate their business as usual.
  • Sell the property, lease it back, and redeploy the sales proceeds into their business or alternative investments.

Each path generates a different stream of cash flows – and comparing their IRRs helps quantify which one yields the greater financial benefit.

By comparing the IRR of each option, we can calculate a differential IRR that compares the two mutually exclusive investments directly. If the differential IRR is positive, it means the sale/leaseback is the superior option based on reinvestment assumptions. If the differential IRR is negative, it would be more beneficial for the user to continue to retain ownership of the property.

Generally speaking, high margin business like tech firms and financial services are typically better served by leasing their real estate while, low margin companies often get a higher return by owning their real estate.

Final Thoughts

Sale/leaseback transactions are a powerful strategy for companies looking to unlock capital while preserving operational continuity. For investors, they offer the potential for attractive, passive income with long-term stability. However, both parties must evaluate the long-term financial and strategic implications.

Whether you’re considering a sale/leaseback to enhance liquidity or expand your investment portfolio, partnering with knowledgeable advisors and conducting thorough financial analysis is key to maximizing value. If your company could benefit from unlocking the value in your owned real estate, contact our team to get a differential IRR analysis on your property to help evaluate the highest return on your capital.

Share

Tags

More Posts

Deal Story | 110 Agnes St

Naomi Brown, CCIM was pleased to represent the sale of 110 Agnes Street in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. Background 110 Agnes St